Do yous like Jeerzy? Well, hopefully you're not a lesbian looking to buy a wedding dress.
Daily News coloumnist Ronnie Polaneczky writes an apologetic human interest story about a young bride-to-be who was denied service by a bridal store because she is a lesbian. "Apologetic?" you ask? Well, yes; thoughtful and kind-hearted straight person Polaneczky, aftering learning all the facts about what happened to Alix Genter (the bride-to-be) and then speaking to Donna (the bridal store owner/service-denier), ultimately finds that he is really, really sorry Genter has to put up with this kind of crap. "...stories [like this one]... make me want to say 'I'm sorry' to gay people for the nonsense they endure from some heterosexuals who give the rest of us straight people a bad name."
Polaneczky is a reasonable person who logically interprets facts about LGBT people, so there's no real reason for me to address his positions. The bridal store owner Donna, however... well, let's just say that I suspect she lives at 1234 Under a Boulder Boulevard, if you know what I mean. I think now would be a great time to educate Donna about how her opinions about LGBT people are a tad off-base.
Donna said a lot of tragically-underinformed, hurtful things about LGBT people in her interview with Polaneczky, including that Genter is a lesbian only because men let her down and thus she relegated herself to women, that LGBT people love to "stir up drama," and that they are crazy aggressors who... plundge knives into restaurant chairs? Yeah, I don't get it, either. However, none of these sentiments were as out-of-touch with reality than her comments about the recognition of same-sex marriage in her state of New Jersey.
The most interesting part of the whole story is why Donna refused to serve Genter. When Donna called Genter to refuse the latter's business, Donna explained that she refused service because 'what Genter was planning' (i.e., her wedding) was "illegal," and that Donna does "not participate in illegal activities." Well, isn't that upstanding of you, Donna? Except for the fact that civil unions have been legal in your state of New Jersey since 19 February 2007, when the Civil Union Act went into effect.
Prior to the passing of that bill by the New Jersey Legislature, there was a five-year-long, highly-publicized New Jersey Supreme Court case called Lewis v. Harris that questioned New Jersey's legal authority to deny the protections and responsibilities of marriage to same-sex couples. Lambda Legal filed Lewis v. Harris in June 2002 on behalf of seven same-sex couples seeking to wed in New Jersey: Mark Lewis and Dennis Winslow, Cindy Meneghin and Maureen Kilian, Craig Hutchison and Chris Lodewyks, Diane Marini and the late Marilyn Maneely, Marcye and Karen Nicholson-McFadden, Saundra Toby-Heath and Alicia Heath-Toby, and Sarah and Suyin Lael. When the case reached the state's Supreme Court, the Justices found unanimously that denying same-sex couples the same legal rights and benefits opposite-sex couples enjoy through marriage violated the state's Constitution. However - and this is the really interesting part - even though the Court found that it is illegal to deny marriage benefits to same-sex couples, the Court didn't actually grant marriage equality. Instead, the Justiced demanded that the Legislature pass legislation making opposite and same-sex couples legally-equal within 180 days. The Legislature did so, and thus the Civil Unions Act was passed and signed into law by then-Governor Jon Corzine. So, Donna, your choice to deny Genter on the basis that her actions are illegal, then, was a legally-unfounded claim, and the long history of that fact should have been apparent to you as a resident of New Jersey. The fact that you live at 1234 Under a Boulder Boulevard notwithstanding, of course.
As further proof that Donna's residence at 1234 Under a Boulder Boulevard is somehow the most remote location in the state with the higest population density in the Union with 1,196 inhabitants per square mile, Donna seems to be totally clueless about the legal recognition of same-sex relationships in her state despite the fact that New Jersey is one of the two most-heated hotspots for marriage equality at present! (The other one is California with it's ongoing legal battles over Perry v. Schwarzenegger.) Before the passage of the New Jersey Civil Unions Act, Lambda Legal had already reviewed the bill's content, and found that it would not actually provide all of the same rights as marriage and established their "Civil Unions Watch" in response. The New Jersey Bar Association came to the same conclusion shortly thereafter. Oh, and New Jerseyans noticed, too: by July 2007 - less than six months after the bill's ratification - 211 of the 1,358 couples unionized under the law reported to Garden State Equality that they had been denied full legal equality under civil unions.
Fortunately for these couples, the Civil Unions Act had already formed a group of legislators tasked with monitaring civil unions, the Civil Unions Review Commission. Since their first meeting on 18 June 2007, the Commission collected complaints from same-sex couples about the state's civil unions and, in December 2008, they released their finding that civil unions don't actually provide full legal equality to same-sex couples mandated by Lewis v. Harris; likewise, the Commission recommended that the New Jersey Legislature change the language of existing marriage laws to be gender-neutral so as to include same-sex couples.
In December 2009 - a full year after the Commission's recommendations - the New Jersey Senate Judiciary Committee voted to approve marriage equality in a 7 to 6 vote. The Senate at large, however, defeated the measure 20 to 14, and thus marriage equality was not brought to New Jersey.
But there are no excuses for you to be so unaware of this news, Donna, for the story continues! In January 2010, Republican Chris Christie assume the position of Governor by defeating incumbent governor Corzine; whereas Corzine had said he would sign marriage equality into law should a bill come to his desk, current Governor Christie supports a constitutional amendment barring same-sex couples for marriage. (For those of you who are really following, yes, the current Governor of New Jersey supports legislation that would withhold legal equality to same-sex couples despite the fact that the state's Supreme Court already ruled that doing so violates the state's constitution and the Civil Union Review Commission declared that they couldn't hold out on equality much longer. Some might say that Christie is aloof or a little... out of his mind; but I disagree, for Christie is clearly not tremendously fond of the rules or your stupid opinions, so this kind of feeble thinking is par for the course for him.) Christie's position on marriage equality means that it's highly unlikely the recommendations of the Civil Union Review Commission will become law through the legislative process.
Likewise, in March 2010, Lambda Legal filed a motion reactivating the case for marriage equality on behalf of the plaintiffs in the original Lewis v. Harris lawsuit, meaning that the state of New Jersey, which is in a pretty serious budget crisis and Christie subsequently underfunded public schools through budget cuts before said cuts were found to be illegal by a district judge, must pay again to rehash an issue that was already decided upon several years ago by the Supreme Court of that state! There is a silver lining for gay and bisexual New Jerseyans, however: this time, the Supreme Court will have to recognize the equalness of your relationships, as they tasked the legislative branch to enact that truth and the Legislature failed to do so, so the Court will have to pick up the slack. Equality will come to you soon, at least at the state level.
With all of this money and all these weddings at stake, you'd think that Donna, who makes her living by selling wedding attire, would be a little more cognisant of the suffering of gays and bisexuals in your state. Now, Donna, listen up, cuz this is very important to your livelihood: according to a 2006 study by The Williams Institute on Sexual Orientation Law and Public Policy, if marriage equality was to become law in New Jersey, "sales by... wedding and tourism-related business would rise by $102.5 million in each of the three years" following the legalization of same-sex marriage. Additionally, New Jersey's gross tax revenue would "rise by $7.2 million per year," and some 1,400 jobs would be created in your state. Yes, that's $307.5 million pumped into your business in the next three years. You'd have to be crazy to turn down that kind of money, Donna. Then again, it's clearly very remote out there at 1234 Under a Boulder Boulevard and, to use your own words, "You know how they get."
Sex + Expertise + Finesse
A sexological blog about sex, body positivism, sexual health, gender, and social justice
Showing posts with label heroes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label heroes. Show all posts
Sunday, August 21, 2011
Sunday, January 16, 2011
Hero: Beth Ditto
Sexpertesse occassionally will feature heroes, people who embody the humanistic principles of this blog. My first hero is the beautiful, talented, and wise Beth Ditto.
Ditto is also an inspiration to trans people and their partners; Ditto's partner Freddie is transgender-identified, having transitioned from female-to-male. He and Ditto have been together supposedly since before his transition. Ditto, then, is a rare notable example of a lesbian-identified woman whose partner transitioned into a man. (Though you ladies might have guessed it, Ditto identifies as a femme.)
Given her outness, then, it might come as a suprise that the controversies that surround Ditto don't focus on her sexuality nor her feminist causes, but instead on her weight. Yeah, you read that correctly: in countries where the status and human-ness of LGBT people are under constant scrutiny (and sometimes up to popular vote), the part that really irks people about Ditto is the size of her waist.
Some, including Alex Bilmes of GQ, have criticized Ditto's weight, claiming her media exposure normalizes unhealthy weights. Ditto's weight has also encircled her success as a fashion icon. Appearing in numerous fashion magazines and runway shows, Ditto is arguably the only fullfigured fashion icon. Marie O’Riordan, former editor of Marie Claire, suggests that Ditto is used by the fashion indstury as a human shield against criticism of their size 0 standard. Ditto, thus, O'Riordan claims, is the fashion industry's attempt to avoid being labeled "body fascists." My questions is, though, does it much matter? No matter their intention in hiring Ditto, she still appears on covers, in spreads, and on runways, meaning, invariably, that some young voluptuous person will see her picture and think, "She's beautiful, and so am I," and thus Ditto's body-positive messages are reaching the very people who need them most.
In light of these criticisms, though, Ditto remains dignified, saying, "It's really interesting to me that people will look at a thin person and go, 'That's a healthy person.' To be thin and to stay really thin, some people literally do coke all the time. Some people smoke cigarettes instead of eating. That's crazy. But that's 'okay' because you look healthier." In 2009, Ditto also expanded her body-positive message by releasing a fashion line with Evans, the UK-based plus-size fashion designer and retailer. For readers in the EU, you can purchase some of Ditto's designs by visiting Evans, located here.
"I got my period just 10 minutes before we got there, and I was totally bleeding. I was doing it with my tranny boyfriend, who I’m in love with, and I was totally bleeding — how radical is that? — and I’m a fat person, and I’m a femme." - Beth Ditto about her NME photo shootBeth Ditto is best known as the leader singer of the indie rock, queercore group Gossip. With Gossip, Ditto is an unwavering advocate for LGBT rights and feminist causes. Ditto, who is a lesbian, tackled many LGBT and feminist issues during her stint as an advice columnist for The Guardian. You can read her column, What Would Beth Ditto do?, by clicking here.
Ditto is also an inspiration to trans people and their partners; Ditto's partner Freddie is transgender-identified, having transitioned from female-to-male. He and Ditto have been together supposedly since before his transition. Ditto, then, is a rare notable example of a lesbian-identified woman whose partner transitioned into a man. (Though you ladies might have guessed it, Ditto identifies as a femme.)
![]() |
| Beth Ditto and her partner Freddie |
Given her outness, then, it might come as a suprise that the controversies that surround Ditto don't focus on her sexuality nor her feminist causes, but instead on her weight. Yeah, you read that correctly: in countries where the status and human-ness of LGBT people are under constant scrutiny (and sometimes up to popular vote), the part that really irks people about Ditto is the size of her waist.
Some, including Alex Bilmes of GQ, have criticized Ditto's weight, claiming her media exposure normalizes unhealthy weights. Ditto's weight has also encircled her success as a fashion icon. Appearing in numerous fashion magazines and runway shows, Ditto is arguably the only fullfigured fashion icon. Marie O’Riordan, former editor of Marie Claire, suggests that Ditto is used by the fashion indstury as a human shield against criticism of their size 0 standard. Ditto, thus, O'Riordan claims, is the fashion industry's attempt to avoid being labeled "body fascists." My questions is, though, does it much matter? No matter their intention in hiring Ditto, she still appears on covers, in spreads, and on runways, meaning, invariably, that some young voluptuous person will see her picture and think, "She's beautiful, and so am I," and thus Ditto's body-positive messages are reaching the very people who need them most.
| Ditto at Paris Fashion Week for Spring 2011 collections |
Ditto's fearless acceptance of her body, her sexuality, her trans partner; her commitment to body positivism and equal rights; and her rocking style make her a Sexpertesse hero. Please support her by purchasing music by The Gossip or her 2011 solo EP on Amazon or iTunes. The world needs more people like Beth Ditto, and her continued success in music is what permits her to have a relevant voice.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


